Skip to content
Monday, November 9, 2026
Premium Desk Lab

Which Players Feature in Troy's Top-Flight Weekly Best XI?

After every single set of Premier League fixtures this season, BBC soccer analyst Troy Deeney will give you his team and gaffer of the week.

Take a look at the latest selections. Let us know if you concur. Provide your feedback.

The Goalkeeper

Jordan Pickford (Everton): A crucial play in the Toffees' comprehensive win against Chelsea came from his outstanding denial to prevent a goal from Enzo Fernandez. Pickford has stepped up when it counts in such moments for Everton throughout the campaign and, hopefully, he maintains this form for the national team in the summer World Cup. Recently, he committed a significant mistake against Arsenal but he has bounced back admirably to deliver for the Toffees.

The Backline

Neco Williams (Nottingham Forest): It was a enormous must-win fixture for Forest away at Tottenham, with their place in the division at stake for both sides. And Williams put in a massive display to aid his side secure a crucial three points in the survival scrap. He provided two key passes, producing when it counted.

Matty Cash (Aston Villa): I did not think West Ham provided a whole lot of danger going forward but Cash stood firm and held the line for Villa. He succeeded in just keeping the play moving. He supplied a lot going forward and also managed to shut down all the Hammers attempted in attack.

James Tarkowski (Everton): It constituted another solid display from the Everton defender. He exhibited his know-how and authority, and was always in the right place. He executed those tackles when called for and, crucially, was a steadying influence in their defense. How Chelsea would love a central defender with such determination, particularly given the uncertain defensive displays they have exhibited at times.

Central Park

Chris Rigg (Sunderland): It amounted to a steady performance from Rigg in a unforgettable Tyne-Wear derby. He did not do anything extraordinary against Newcastle but he executed everything to a very high standard. With Rigg, you understand exactly what to expect from him.

James Garner (Everton): He might have relaxed after receiving a call-up to the Three Lions team recently. But on the contrary, he got on with it and produced a great shift. It was a lovely assist from him to Beto for Everton's first goal. From my time with him at Watford, I am aware he's synonymous with relentless work rate and big tackles. He possesses all the attributes and I am confident he does well for England to force his way into that World Cup squad.

John McGinn (Aston Villa): He's their skipper, on-field general and heartbeat. It's been two enormous displays in the space of a week from him. Villa are a respectable team. But McGinn transforms them into a exceptional one. If they are to secure the Champions League places and challenge for the European title, they depend on him to maintain his form at this level.

Harry Wilson (Fulham): He has made a knack of netting important goals and he repeated the trick once more this week. I wonder how they can possibly fill the void if he decides to move on. They are unlikely to pay a huge sum on somebody with his qualities. They need him to put pen to paper on a renewal as he is a hugely key component of that Cottagers team.

The Forwards

Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United): It feels like the Portugal midfielder is establishing himself as a permanent fixture in the weekly best XI. You have to select him again following one more goal, and additionally causing the James Hill own goal. How long can United remain mediocre and keep him before he feels it is time to depart the club?

Beto (Everton): On this occasion, we have two forwards who are at opposite stages in their professional journey. I have doubts Beto is a lasting answer for the Merseyside club's attacking woes, but manager David Moyes is getting the best out of him at the moment. It is remarkable considering how subpar he was during the early stages.

Danny Welbeck (Brighton): He was snubbed by Thomas Tuchel again for the national squad, at a point when they need support to skipper Harry Kane. But Welbeck continued to deliver for the Albion with a two goals, to beat reigning champions Liverpool, and bring his goal count to 12 goals for the campaign.

Manager of the Week

David Moyes (Everton): The fixture between Everton and Chelsea was a perfect encapsulation of old school against new school. Chelsea's manager Liam Rosenior is attempting to find his way at the beginning of his coaching journey but Moyes formulated a flawless strategy to secure a comprehensive win. The Toffees were more adventurous and more powerful in all departments of the game and it was a massive win for them.

What's your verdict with Deeney's picks? Who would be your Team of the Week? Have your say.

About the author

Morgan Skinner DDS

Ergonomics specialist with 10 years of experience in workspace optimization and office furniture design.

Premium Desk Lab

Type to search articles.